The Schwan's Scoop

The Official Blog of Schwan's Home Service

Pie vs. Pie

By Schwan's Home Service, September 27, 2016

Schwan's Pies

When pies go to battle, it’s a win-win – but just for fun, here’s our tally of great pie face-offs and our projected winners.

Schwan's Pumpkin Pie     Schwan's Old-Fashioned Apple Pie
Most American? Pumpkin Pie vs. Old-Fashioned Apple Pie

Winner: Too close to call!

While Pumpkin Pie’s dominance at the all-American holiday Thanksgiving makes it pretty darn patriotic, our Old-Fashioned Apple Pie contains a full pound of apples! The saying is “As American as Apple Pie” – but we’re still on the fence with this one.

Schwan's Pumpkin Pie     Schwan's Pumpkin Creme Pie
Best Thanksgiving Dinner Encore? Pumpkin Pie vs. Pumpkin Crème Pie

Winner: It’s a draw.

Strict traditionalists might prefer Pumpkin Pie, but others may favor the Pumpkin Crème Pie for its delicate layers of pumpkin and crème and artful rosettes.

Schwan's Pumpkin Creme Pie     Schwan's Chocolate Creme Pie
Best Crème Pie?  Pumpkin Crème Pie vs. Chocolate Crème Pie

Winner: Can’t talk, too busy eating pie.

This just depends on your mood. For chocolaty decadence, go for Chocolate Crème Pie. For warm autumnal flavors, you can’t beat Pumpkin Crème Pie.